baseof.html

Our Work

Higher Education Finance

Higher Education Finance

Introduction

The higher education system is afflicted by a crisis of quality, affordability, and access that belies its role in building an equitable and just society.

The broken system has led to an array of interrelated problems in education, from extremely burdensome debt loads to scant student support and inadequate academic programs. Students have had to shoulder the burden of higher education unfairly.

We develop pilots, studies, and research with the aim of gaining insight into the student debt crisis and finding the most high-impact interventions to alleviate debt and improve the higher education system. Our pilot and policy design within this initiative focus on income share agreements (ISAs).

Working with us

If you’re interested in working with us, email jfi@jainfamilyinstitute.org. We primarily partner with policymakers, universities, college access organizations, foundations, and ISA providers. We provide ISA analytics, pilot operationalization, and program design, terms, and evaluation.

In spring 2020, we began our partnership with the Student Freedom Initiative, a major new nonprofit fund, led by Robert F. Smith, that will offer income-contingent financing to students at historically Black colleges and universities.

ISA Pilots

Income Share Agreements (ISAs) are an alternative to student debt in which students agree to pay a percentage of their income over a limited period of time rather than paying principal and interest on a fixed schedule. If students earn less, they end up paying less; if they earn more, they pay more. ISAs adjust with the students’ ability to repay. We see ISAs as a tool for addressing a broad array of issues in education. To students, ISAs are a financial aid program that provides tuition funding in exchange for a defined percentage of post-graduation income. To schools and investors, ISAs are a financial product that generates commercial and social returns. Unlike student loans, ISAs shift the risk involved in pursuing higher education from the student onto the investor.

JFI builds pilot programs to prove out new applications of the ISA model and to demonstrate its commercial viability and social impact. JFI’s ISA pilots are devised and operated in partnership with educational institutions, scholarship funds, training providers, college access organizations, various ISA companies, and a wide range of philanthropic, impact, and market-rate investors. Each pilot is built to expand the public case for ISAs, rigorously document the impact on students, and generate reliable payments data that sets the stage for scale capital. In 2016, JFI collaborated with Purdue University and Vemo Education to design and launch the nation’s first large-scale ISA program. JFI pilots have since provided financing to students in Colorado, Washington, D.C., Minnesota, Illinois, and Wisconsin — reaching institutions that range from General Assembly to UW-Madison. In 2019, we began working with the San Diego Workforce Partnership on ISAs for workforce-training programs. In the course of this work, JFI has developed expert capacities in capital structuring, program design, fundraising, and ISA underwriting.

ISA Analytics and Income-Contingent Financing Research

JFI’s ISA research has two major strands. First, in the course of our pilot-design work, we have constructed the most comprehensive ISA analytics in existence — a Monte Carlo simulation combining dozens of public, private, and proprietary datasets to model a host of ISA structures, features, and terms. We’ve adapted this framework to project returns to education in our scholarship, and have used it to aid our partners in pilot design.

Second, we produce theoretical and empirical research on the implications of ISAs and other forms of income-driven repayment as financing instruments for higher education, expanding academic and popular discourse on returns to education, college affordability, risk preferences, and asymmetrical information.

Millennial Student Debt

JFI’s Millennial Student Debt Project is a research project investigating financial, workforce, and geospatial behavior of millennials with student debt. The study aims to present a country-wide analysis and visualization of student debt and its relationship with demographic characteristics, school characteristics, and labor market characteristics, and how these relationships have changed over the past decade.

The project name refers to the key focus of our study–student debt, in its many forms, sizes and payment schemes–but we are especially interested in the decisions leading up to and following debt take-up. Additionally, JFI’s research on the effects of institutional concentration on net tuition costs, as well as the relationship between federal/state funding and workforce trends, will serve to complement and contextualize our research on student debt. JFI purchased two comprehensive and nationally-representative credit bureau datasets on the millennial cohort to supplement this project.

View the first post in the series here.

Partners

  • Arnold Ventures
  • Better Future Forward
  • College Possible
  • The Dream.US
  • Education Finance Institute
  • The Jack Kent Cooke Foundation
  • Lumni
  • Opportunity @ Work
  • Outcome
  • Purdue University
  • Rockefeller Foundation
  • Russell Sage Foundation
  • San Diego Workforce Partnership
  • Vaughn College of Aeronautics

Q&A

  • What is higher education finance?  

  • Why is higher education finance in the news? 

  • How do students ordinarily pay for school? 

  • What is an income share agreement? 

  • Doesn’t the federal government offer something like income share agreements? 

  • How does IDR differ from ISAs? 

  • What other features may ISAs have to protect students? 

  • Why write that “ISAs may be built” with these features, instead of “ISAs are built” with these features? 

  • Would an ISA system push students into the highest-paying majors? 

  • Does the Jain Family Institute offer ISAs? 

  • What does JFI do with ISAs? 

  • What type of ISA and higher education research does JFI conduct? 

  • Given the expense, is college worth it? 

  • Does JFI advocate for ISAs? 

  • How can I get an ISA if JFI doesn’t provide them? 

  • I’m an institution interested in piloting ISAs. How can we work together? 

our-work / single.html